<img height="1" width="1" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=139797240013274&amp;ev=PageView &amp;noscript=1">
Call 1.800.323.9974
Free Strategy Call

An agent recruiting turnaround story

By Frank Klesitz in Frank's Diary on May 2, 2025

A story today to help you improve your agent recruiting results…

In February, I spoke with a client who wasn’t getting enough recruiting appointments to hit his goal of one new agent a month.

I looked at his video email marketing performance…

“To whom exactly are we sending these to again?" I asked. "Your topics are great, but your open and click-through rates on your emails are low.”

“I have to be honest with you,” he replied. “It’s the whole MLS. I didn’t have any agent database when I started. You told me not to do that, but I did it anyway. I’m sorry.”

 🤦  ⬅️ My response.

I pulled up our 3-step system: https://www.getvyral.com/system

Here’s how I scored him:

  1. FAIL: He just started spamming all the agents in town. Not sure how this got past us. Rather, he needed to get permission from his target market to stay in touch first.
  2. PASS: He was running the monthly implementation of our service just fine to stay in touch and position himself as a peer leader. Two helpful Q&A videos a month, one lead generation message a month, retargeting ads, etc.
  3. PASS: His assistant called the agents watching his videos to offer free coaching calls, which was great. He or she 

Here’s what we did:

I deleted all the agents in his email marketing program, except the ones who clicked a link since he started. He was left with only 42 agents in his warm database.

He then bought a cold list of 674 local real estate agents who have been licensed for three or fewer years and sold at least 3 houses. This is his perfect-fit agent.

“What’s the #1 thing you can offer these agents to solve their most pressing problem to start a relationship, being you’re one of the top listing agents in town?” I asked.

“My listing presentation, I’m sure they would love it."

His assistant called all 674 agents three times on that list back in March with this script…

“Hi Jane, I work for Matt (last name withheld), who’s the #3 listing agent in town with RE/Max. He asked me to call to ask your permission to mail you a copy of his listing presentation. Would you be interested in reading it? It’s how we’re getting 3.5% commissions by addressing modern seller needs. He thinks it can help you too. It’s free, and it’s our way to start a relationship with you. I can email it or FedEx it to you, which do you prefer?”

I was told 198 agents replied and asked for his listing presentation. He then added them to his permission-based database, which now totals 240 local agents in his target market.

I called him up today ask how his April went.

“Frank, you won’t believe this. I’ve gone on 8 recruiting appointments and found 3 agents who are a perfect fit for my team. Thank you!”

The lesson here is to pick a target market and reach out to them with an easy offer to solve their problem in return for their consent to stay in touch.

That's how you build a great database in any niche, warm them up with us, and get more high quality appointments.

If you need to recruit, I invite you to do the same.

P.S. I'm at the Radio and Television Experts event in Nashville today. I'll write you next week of what I learned here - these are many of the top performing real estate teams in the country. The key theme: getting more out of what you already have.

5d1b359997d1f679aa2565bb

 


 

Topics: Frank's Diary

Frank Klesitz

Written by Frank Klesitz

Frank Klesitz is the CEO and founder of Vyral Marketing

    Recent Posts